Apple will be judged for planned obsolescence in Paris in 2027
The American manufacturer will have to answer before the French courts for alleged obstacles to the repair of its iPhones, following a complaint from the HOP association.
Apple will be the subject of a planned obsolescence trial in Paris in 2027. The HOP association – Stop Planned Obsolescence – announces the upcoming opening of a trial targeting Apple for planned obsolescence by obstruction of repair. The investigation opened in 2023 by the Paris prosecutor's office will lead to the referral of the iPhone manufacturer to the criminal court. “The first hearing will take place on February 25, 2027 and the pleadings will take place over several days in June 2027,” announces the association.
A complaint focused on the limitation of repairs
HOP, in its complaint, sought to establish that Apple deliberately restricts the possibilities of repairing its phones by blocking the use of spare parts not approved by the company. This technical practice, called matching or serialization, makes the proper functioning of a spare part depend on its validation by the operating system, in particular according to its correspondence with the serial number of the device.
The association denounced: "This practice has recently affected the parts most frequently subject to breakdowns (screens, battery, camera, etc.). It allows the manufacturer to limit the possibilities for repair, particularly for non-approved repairers." HOP aims for serialization, a little-known practice: Apple assigns a digital marking to its spare parts so that iPhones automatically identify them when they are installed. When the smartphone does not recognize an official spare part, it may block its operation or limit some of its functionalities.
According to HOP, even original parts can be restricted, whether new or used, if “the intervention is not approved by Apple” via software and remotely – a problem which has affected “for several years the parts most frequently subject to breakdowns (screens, battery, camera, etc.)”. A problem that is all the more annoying as Apple stores currently charge more than 400 euros for the replacement of a latest generation iPhone screen. The association specifies to Le Monde that “200 kg of raw materials are necessary for the production of a smartphone”.
HOP cited, in its complaint filed in 2022, the case of an iPhone
HOP notably bases its complaint on the basis of article L441-3 of the Consumer Code, which since 2021 has prohibited any technique, including software, aimed at preventing the repair or reconditioning of a device outside the commercial circuits approved by its manufacturer. These measures are, for the record, following the vote, in 2020, of the anti-waste law for a circular economy. According to HOP, the European Union has “taken the lead and further regulated practices via the directive on the right to repair”.
After the vote and then promulgation of this law, Apple implemented several initiatives to simplify the repair of its devices outside its network. The company notably launched its Self Service Repair program at the end of 2022 in Europe. This gives customers access to certain original Apple parts and repair manuals, for prices comparable to those charged in stores.
Recent developments, but considered insufficient
The HOP association believes that this is progress, while questioning its real scope. She argues: “If Apple has announced from 2022 that it has limited serialization practices on new iPhones and now allows third parties to validate certain repairs, these improvements remain to be confirmed over time. For HOP, this development reveals a progressive consideration of the serious difficulties posed by serialization for repair and reconditioning outside approved circuits”.
For its part, Apple reacted briefly, quoted by AFP: “We strongly contest these unfounded allegations.”
HOP has already won its case against Apple. In 2017, the association filed a complaint for planned obsolescence, this time linked to software updates which caused the slowdown of eligible phones. The DGCCRF opened an investigation, which resulted in a fine of 25 million euros as part of a criminal settlement (without trial).
In 2027, Apple will not be the only big name in tech to have to defend its practices in court. Following a complaint filed in 2017, HOP obtained the opening of a trial against Epson. The company is accused of planned obsolescence practices and deceptive commercial practices concerning the management, by its printers, of the renewal of ink cartridges or ink pads. A first hearing took place in July 2026. The pleadings are now scheduled for February 25, 2027.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only Journal du Net reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- Journal du Net17 Nov, 20:23
| Publisher Journal du Net (general tier) | +72 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 74 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.
