“Deleterious for the French economy”, “unfair”, “wobbly”… The Zucman tax divides economists
Gabriel Zucman is organizing a summit on November 21 to promote his proposed tax on assets above 100 million euros. A measure contested by certain more liberal specialists, like Philippe Aghion.
A five-star cast. On November 21, American economic stars Paul Krugman and Joseph Stiglitz – both Nobel Prize winners – will attend the “Paris against the international oligarchy” Summit, organized at the Théâtre de la Concorde, at the initiative of the International Tax Observatory, directed by Gabriel Zucman. On this occasion, the French economist published a work with the title and subtitle The Paris Manifesto, signed by around a hundred personalities.
The Berkeley professor continues his relentless lobbying in favor of his 2% tax on assets above 100 million euros. On November 3, however, he experienced a setback. Californians rejected, by referendum, his alternative proposal to proceed with a single 5% levy.
“The billionaires of Silicon Valley have won this battle but they will lose the war,” reacted the winner of the prestigious American Clark Medal. “Tax the entirety” of the wealth of the richGabriel Zucman believes that only his tax makes it possible to resolve the problem of fairness in tax matters. In 2023, a study by the Institute of Public Policy (IPP) on French taxpayers showed that “the effective tax rate becomes regressive at the top of the distribution, going from 45% for the richest 0.1%, to 25% for the richest 0.0002% (75 tax households).
» In question, the use of asset holding companies, legal systems which allow their dividends to be held almost tax-free. When investing for your future or even going into debt is no longer enough: this invisible evil which fuels the anger of young people around the world “The rich always find ways to declare very little income, the only way to tax them effectively is to tax their entire assets (professional assets included),” argues the economist. In France, his measure is defended by the Nobel Prize winner Esther Duflo and, of course, by Thomas Piketty, who was his thesis director, as well as that of Camille Landais, another supporter.
In Parliament, it was supported, in 2025, by the entire left, without it succeeding in imposing it. The rebellious Jean-Luc Mélenchon included it in his presidential program. Counter-offensive The subject is, however, very divisive.
Other more liberal economists, led in particular by Antoine Levy, also a teacher at Berkeley, have increased their criticism on social networks, exchanging with each other on dedicated WhatsApp loops. Nobel Prize winner Philippe Aghion judges that “this tax would be harmful to the French economy. California didn't want it, why should France be the breeding ground for shaky ideas?
»Main criticism: the risk of tax exile. “The people concerned will refuse to be taxed this much for several years in a row, they will leave,” warns François Geerolf, economist at the IFE. It has never been easier to live elsewhere, especially in the European Union.
» Anticipating this exile, the Economic Analysis Council (CAE), attached to Matignon, estimates that the yield from the tax would not exceed 5 billion euros, far from the 20 billion advanced by its architect. “We have a lot of employees stuck on the minimum wage”: is the exemption from employer contributions a brake on wage increases? Its detractors also warn of the risks for the competitiveness of businesses, particularly start-ups.
“These companies have a theoretical and volatile valuation and do not generate income for their shareholders, it is therefore unfair to tax them,” says Xavier Jaravel, deputy president of the CAE, former student of Philippe Aghion. To pay the tax, the owners of Mistral AI could thus be forced to transfer their shares to the State. “Innovative companies would no longer be created in France,” continues Philippe Aghion.
Gabriel Zucman reasons in a world where growth is not driven by innovation: yet this is what France needs.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only Challenges reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- Challenges19 Nov, 13:00
| Publisher Challenges (established tier) | +76 |
| Checkable figures cited | +3 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 81 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.
