OPINION. “Corporate tax: putting the tax right side up”
Faced with a corporate tax system considered unfair, where SMEs pay a higher effective corporate tax rate than large groups, a legislative proposal is emerging. It aims to establish a progressive scale for corporate…
By Grégory Blanc, senator Place Publique, vice-president of the finance committee
France has made progressivity the heart of its income tax, but it has forgotten it for its businesses. Since 2022, corporate tax (IS) has hit the profit of the plumbing or masonry workshop at 25%, like that of the group listed on the CAC 40. The equality of the facade thus masks a real injustice: thanks to tax integration, transfer prices and loss carryovers, large groups actually pay around 14%, SMEs around 21%. We tax more those who have the least margins, in other words the IS works in reverse.
When examining this finance bill, I propose to put it right side up: five tranches, applied by fraction of profit, as for income tax. 10% up to €100,000, 15% up to €250,000, 25% up to 1.5 million, 28% up to 10 million, 30% beyond. All beneficiary SMEs pay less; large groups, a little more. This scale, necessarily marginal, is generally self-financing in view of the figures for the 2025 collection. And the thresholds are assessed at group level: it is impossible to divide a company to change bracket.
With this reform, it is not a simple redistribution measure, but rather an economic policy measure, supporting production.
Because investment stalls. In the third quarter, GDP fell by 0.1% and business investment by 0.4%. The desire is nevertheless there: 45% of SME managers plan to invest this year, but 17% are struggling to finance their projects. The brake is not the will, it is the balance sheet.
Let's take a company with eight employees which generates €95,000 in profit. She now pays €19,500 in tax. With this scale, she would pay €9,500, or €10,000 more each year, to invest without borrowing. The impact is significant.
Indeed, our young companies suffer from the weakness of their equity, they struggle to find lenders to refinance themselves, often with the only prospect of opening up their capital... what business leader takes risks, "tightens his belt" at start-up, to offer the fruit of these efforts to the first investor who comes along? Valuing the risk and commitment of those who undertake requires a reform of our taxation. With this proposal, during their first five years, each euro of profit retained is a euro that they will neither have to borrow nor give up.
The challenge is even more acute for transmission. 370,000 companies could change hands by 2030; in 2024, just 26,000 have done so. The buyer goes into debt to buy, then repays from the profits: a company taken over is undercapitalized by construction. If the tax levies too early, transmission fails, and with it local employment, subcontracting, know-how.
We must therefore go further and reward the profit that remains in the company. During the five years following a creation or takeover, the lower tranches could be increased when the profit is put in reserve. Tax would cease to be a drain and become a lever for consolidating productive capital.
The issue goes beyond the balance sheet of each company. The ecological transition requires our SMEs to invest massively: decarbonizing a process, renovating a building, electrifying a fleet. These investments are first financed with equity, because banks lend to those who already have it. An undercapitalized SME does not decarbonize: it waits. And each year of waiting is paid for in lost competitiveness.
It will be objected that increasing taxes on large groups would scare away investment. The argument deserves better than a cliché. A rate of 30% beyond 25 million euros of profit would place us at the level of Germany, not above it. It only affects the highest fraction of profits, the one which often remunerates the shareholder more than it finances the tool.
In our territories, it is companies with ten, twenty or fifty employees who run the towns, train the apprentices, and keep subcontracting going. They do not relocate. They therefore deserve a tax that recognizes them, this is where our work as legislators comes in.
The left has talked about business for too long to tax it; the right thought it was defending it by uniformly lowering rates. Both hit the wrong target. It is not a question of making the company lighter or heavier, but of adjusting the tax to each person's reality.
An economy that produces is an economy that manages to capitalize to invest, and not to distribute dividends which are transformed at the end of the cycle into passive savings. Let us also remember that one additional point of growth by 2032 would allow us to effortlessly resolve almost half of the budgetary adjustments to be made, and would mechanically allow us to lower our debt ratio by 15 points. This is why it is urgent to stop taxing the hardest those who build, choose to invest, take risks, and who contribute the most to the growth of our country's wealth. Making corporate tax progressive means acting for greater justice but also and above all for greater economic efficiency.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only La Tribune reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- La Tribune17 Nov, 08:40
| Publisher La Tribune (established tier) | +76 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 78 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.
