The paperExchangeCrypto WikiWikiAcademynotitiaplatform.com
Sign in
● LIVE
CAC 408 167,6▲ 0.25%S&P 5007 323,6▼ 0.23%EURO STOXX6 187,7▲ 0.54%BTC/USD63 811▼ 1.22%ETH/USD1 804,8▼ 0.35%EUR/USD1.10▲ 0.20%BRENT89.60▲ 0.48%GOLD3 729▼ 0.34%OAT 10Y5.07%▼ 0.73%VIX22.17▼ 9.73%CAC 408 167,6▲ 0.25%S&P 5007 323,6▼ 0.23%EURO STOXX6 187,7▲ 0.54%BTC/USD63 811▼ 1.22%ETH/USD1 804,8▼ 0.35%EUR/USD1.10▲ 0.20%BRENT89.60▲ 0.48%GOLD3 729▼ 0.34%OAT 10Y5.07%▼ 0.73%VIX22.17▼ 9.73%
 
Europe edition
Notitia
← Back
TechnologyNumerama

Tesla autonomous driving (FSD): France accused of leading a secret revolt to block its approval

The account

N
Numerama
Newswire · 2 h ago
◌ Single source2 min read
✦ Explain it to me
Tesla autonomous driving (FSD): France accused of leading a secret revolt to block its approval

Receive a summary of important news every evening with Le Récap’

Tesla only has one (major) obstacle left before offering supervised driving throughout Europe. Its FSD, renamed Tesla Assisted Driving on the continent, is already authorized in eleven EU countries. Finland was the last to agree, on November 10. To be valid in the 27 countries, the authorization must still pass by a vote of the TCMV, the technical committee on which the Member States sit, by qualified majority: at least 15 countries representing 65% of the population.

However, this Wednesday, November 18, the account X FSD in Denmark (@FSDEurope) accused France of maneuvering behind the scenes to cause this vote to fail. The weight of Paris matters, because without France and Germany, which together account for around a third of the EU population, the 65% threshold would become almost impossible to reach.

According to the @FSDEurope account, a source working in the administration of a Member State revealed to him that Paris sent an email to all EU countries. France would affirm that the FSD does not respect certain regulatory requirements, in particular on speed, and would push its partners to vote no.

EXCLUSIVE: FRANCE WANTS ITS TESLA FSD COMMUNICATIONS KEPT SECRET! A source working inside an EU member state told me that France emailed ALL EU member states, arguing that Tesla FSD (Supervised) does not meet certain regulatory requirements, raising concerns about… https://t.co/zfQXzjk67L pic.twitter.com/DkNLV5lKmw

To obtain these messages, the author of the account filed requests for access to administrative documents in several European countries. In Bulgaria, the Ministry of Transport replied that it had not had any exchanges with Paris on the subject. However, the Bulgarian automobile regulator refused to forward the correspondence to him, because the French authorities requested that “all correspondence concerning the FSD” remain confidential. A response which tends to confirm the rumor.

The account has already published real administrative documents, such as a Bulgarian note from August 11 which expressed concern about an FSD capable of driving at 70 km/h on a road limited to 50 km/h. On the other hand, the Bulgarian refusal only proves that France requested secrecy regarding its exchanges. No one has seen the famous emails, and FSDEurope itself acknowledges that the instruction to vote no has not been independently verified.

It should also be kept in mind that the account has a very strong opinion on possible opponents of the FSD. In response to a message from Philippe Tabarot, Minister of Transport, he called the latter a “liar” and accused him of being “against the FSD”. As for secrecy, the preparatory discussions for a regulatory decision are not necessarily public in any case.

If the accusation were true, it would go against recent developments in the government's discourse. On July 22, Philippe Tabarot judged the security guarantees “still sufficient for authorization as it stands”. Then on September 2, after a videoconference with Elon Musk, he explained on X that the French authorities were working “closely with Tesla on the technical adaptations which will allow France to support its approval”.

Two equipped cars were to be tested on French roads. However, the criticisms made against Paris do not come out of nowhere: the FSD's speed limit margin was reduced from 50% to 10% above the limit, a modification validated on November 3 by the RDW, the Dutch regulator behind the first authorization.

Demanding corrections before voting would therefore not constitute sabotage in itself, especially when these corrections end up arriving so quickly in Tesla vehicles already using FSD.

The European Union-wide vote should not take place before the TCMV meeting in December, after two missed meetings, on June 30 and then October 6. Germany said it was ready to plead for rapid approval, while France has still not authorized the system on its roads. Let us also remember that if the European Union opposes the approval of the system, the countries which have authorized it by way of derogation would lose the possibility of using it. The fate of the FSD therefore remains completely unclear for the moment.

Not everyone can afford to pay for information. That’s why we keep our journalism open to everyone.

But if you can, here are three good reasons to support our work:

If you believe in a free web and quality information accessible to as many people as possible, join Numerama+.

Add Numerama to your home screen and stay connected to the future!

The future doesn't wait: anticipate the future of new technologies and AI by reading AlwaysPlus for free, every Thursday in your inbox!

Source · Numerama ↗

Machine-translated from French

Not cross-checked yet

Only Numerama reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.

The reports
  1. Numerama
    19 Nov, 08:31
Trust score: 74/100
Publisher Numerama (general tier)+72
Detailed summary+2
Total74

Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.