The paperExchangeCrypto WikiWikiAcademynotitiaplatform.com
Sign in
● LIVE
CAC 407 927,8▼ 1.89%S&P 5006 910,4▼ 3.70%EURO STOXX5 942▼ 2.81%BTC/USD58 165▼ 5.60%ETH/USD1 595,2▼ 8.62%EUR/USD1.10▼ 0.06%BRENT90.01▲ 0.64%GOLD3 523,7▼ 4.39%OAT 10Y4.91%▼ 2.77%VIX37.66▲ 32.42%CAC 407 927,8▼ 1.89%S&P 5006 910,4▼ 3.70%EURO STOXX5 942▼ 2.81%BTC/USD58 165▼ 5.60%ETH/USD1 595,2▼ 8.62%EUR/USD1.10▼ 0.06%BRENT90.01▲ 0.64%GOLD3 523,7▼ 4.39%OAT 10Y4.91%▼ 2.77%VIX37.66▲ 32.42%
 
Europe edition
Notitia
← Back
EconomyChallenges

New controversy for the most expensive tax loophole: MPs warn of the failing fight against CIR fraud

The Research Tax Credit (CIR) is regularly singled out for its cost of 7.3 billion euros. A parliamentary report published Thursday, November 19 also warns of the low number of checks on beneficiaries.

C
Challenges
Newswire · 9 h ago
◌ Single source2 min read
✦ Explain it to me
New controversy for the most expensive tax loophole: MPs warn of the failing fight against CIR fraud

This is one of the most controversial tax loopholes. The Research Tax Credit (CIR), introduced in 1983, aims to support research and development (R&D) spending by companies. In 2025, it benefited 17,079 companies for a total cost of 7.3 billion euros, making it the most expensive tax loophole – there are 457.

Manufacturers defend it tooth and nail, believing that it is necessary to develop innovation, while France's share of private research remains below the OECD average. But the effectiveness of the CIR is regularly criticized by several economists and reports. And while the Court of Auditors recently called for it to be scaled back, another criticism resurfaces: in their report devoted to the fight against tax evasion, published Thursday, November 19, deputies Nicolas Sansu (PCF) and Mathilde Feld (LFI) devoted a section to this tax loophole.

They point to a lack of control over the granting of the system, making it impossible, according to them, to detect the extent of potential fraud. Only 1.8% of beneficiaries are controlled. Control of the system is ensured by the General Directorate of Public Finances (DGFIP), which must ensure that companies respect the conditions for obtaining it, with supporting evidence. These controls, often complex, require the expertise of people competent in scientific matters.

The DGFIP then relies on the General Directorate of Research and Innovation (DGRI), attached to the Ministry of Higher Education and Research, and its regional academic delegates for research and innovation – the Drari –, whose experts come from public organizations such as the CNRS. Adam Nicol (Grant Thornton): “It is reasonable to question the Research Tax Credit” However, the number of files processed has decreased significantly over the last ten years. They went from 748 to 310.

This corresponds to a control rate of 1.8% of grants granted. “The means are absolutely not enough,” criticizes Nicolas Sansu. A whole bunch of files escape scientific control.

» In 2025, controls cost 822,000 euros, or 2,650 euros per file. “The cost of the expert assessments is out of all proportion to the cost of the system for the State or the rectified amounts,” criticize the rapporteurs. Use of consulting firms They calculate that systematic recourse to the granting of the CIR would represent an annual expenditure of 45.3 million euros, to be put into perspective with the 7.3 billion allocated.

The authors therefore request that the DGRI's control resources be strengthened. “A generalization of controls to all first CIR applications, renewed at regular intervals, would represent a profitable investment for the State and would allow better targeting of research aid,” argue the deputies. “It is used for everything except to finance research”: the charge of Nobel Prize winner Philippe Aghion against the wasted billions of the CIR Another aspect of the report: it warns about the use of consulting firms in the constitution of files for granting the CIR.

The situation “delights a certain number of pharmacies which prepare research tax credit application files and which provide assistance when there are controls,” explained Patrick Martin, the president of Medef, during his hearing in the Senate in April 2025 before the commission of inquiry into business aid. We estimate that 20 to 30% of the amount allocated under the Research Tax Credit is thus absorbed. » To combat windfall effects, the rapporteurs call for the establishment of a stricter regulatory framework for the use of these firms, which would involve labeling, as well as supervision of their remuneration.

Source · Challenges ↗

Machine-translated from French

Not cross-checked yet

Only Challenges reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.

The reports
  1. Challenges
    20 Nov, 13:37
Trust score: 81/100
Publisher Challenges (established tier)+76
Checkable figures cited+3
Detailed summary+2
Total81

Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.