The paperExchangeCrypto WikiWikiAcademynotitiaplatform.com
Sign in
● LIVE
CAC 408 352▼ 0.20%S&P 5007 416,6▼ 1.92%EURO STOXX6 348,4▼ 0.60%BTC/USD64 587▼ 0.48%ETH/USD1 827,5▲ 0.39%EUR/USD1.10▲ 0.09%BRENT91.66▼ 0.84%GOLD3 877,9▲ 0.65%OAT 10Y5.12%▼ 0.64%VIX22.91▲ 18.70%CAC 408 352▼ 0.20%S&P 5007 416,6▼ 1.92%EURO STOXX6 348,4▼ 0.60%BTC/USD64 587▼ 0.48%ETH/USD1 827,5▲ 0.39%EUR/USD1.10▲ 0.09%BRENT91.66▼ 0.84%GOLD3 877,9▲ 0.65%OAT 10Y5.12%▼ 0.64%VIX22.91▲ 18.70%
 
Europe edition
Notitia
← Back
EconomyEuronews

Turning Italian? Why Italy is the G7's unlikely fiscal role model

HSBC says every G7 member will need Italian-style primary surpluses to stabilise debt, as Rome borrows more cheaply than Paris ahead of an election-year budget.

E
Euronews
Newswire · 54 min ago
◌ Single source2 min read
✦ Explain it to me
Turning Italian? Why Italy is the G7's unlikely fiscal role model

In September 1992, Italy was the cautionary tale of European finance. The lira was forced out of the European exchange rate mechanism, the currency slumped, and Rome had to convince investors that it could still pay its bills. What followed was more than three decades of belt-tightening that Italians still argue about.

Year after year, the state collected more in revenue than it spent, before counting the interest on its debt. Economists call this a primary surplus. Italy has posted one in 28 of the 34 years since 1992, according to International Monetary Fund data.

Now one of the world's largest banks says the rest of the Group of Seven will have to do the same. "Every member of the G7 will have to follow Italy," Janet Henry, global chief economist at HSBC, said in a note last week titled "Turning Italian? ".

Her argument rests on simple arithmetic. When the interest rate a government pays on its debt stays above the growth rate of its economy, debt keeps rising as a share of output, unless the government spends less than it collects before interest. With borrowing costs high across advanced economies, Henry expects that gap to persist.

A lesson Italy learned the hard wayHenry was careful not to turn Italy into a model pupil. "Italy is no poster child: the debt stock is still high, but it has run a persistent primary surplus for many years, initially forced by a severe currency and debt crisis in 1992," she said. The difference, in her view, is that Rome has kept up the effort for decades, while the others have barely started.

"Unlike Italy, none of the others are on track for a prolonged adjustment," Henry said. Only countries that have felt some pressure from bond markets, such as the United Kingdom, have tried to tackle their deficits over the past year, she added. Not even the United States escapes the problem.

Henry cited an estimate by the director of the Congressional Budget Office, the US fiscal watchdog, that stabilising American debt through growth alone would require nominal growth of 7-8% a year at current rates. She also warned that the easy exits are closed. Governments cannot slash spending the way Greece and Portugal did after the eurozone crisis, and productivity gains from artificial intelligence may not easily turn into higher tax revenue.

"Difficult political choices lie ahead," she said. Only one G7 country spends less than it collectsThe latest IMF figures show how lonely Italy's position is. According to the Fund's October Fiscal Monitor, Italy is on course for a primary surplus of 1% of GDP this year, rising to 1.

2% in 2027. It is the only G7 economy expected to run one. France is heading for a primary deficit of 2.

9% of GDP this year. Germany, long the eurozone's fiscal disciplinarian, is projected to run a primary deficit of 3. 4% as it ramps up spending on defence and infrastructure.

The United States is expected to run a primary deficit of 4. 9%, Canada 2. 6%, and Japan and the UK about 1.

2% each. How far the others would have to travel is a matter of debate. Writing in the IMF's Finance & Development magazine in March, economist Zsolt Darvas estimated that France and the United States would each need a primary surplus of 1.

3% of GDP to stabilise their debt, and the UK 1. 8%. For France, that would mean improving its budget by more than four percentage points of GDP.

Darvas noted that Paris has hit the required level only six times in five decades. Italy, to be clear, still carries the heavier load. The IMF expects its public debt to reach 137.

9% of GDP this year, the highest in the eurozone and above Greece's 136%. France stands at 118. 5%.

Bond markets have already changed their mindsInvestors appear to have reached a similar conclusion to HSBC. On Monday at 13:26 CET, Italy's 10-year government bond yielded 4. 43%, while France's equivalent OAT yielded 4.

93%. That means Rome is borrowing for a decade at half a percentage point less than Paris. On Friday, the gap closed at 50 basis points, the widest in Italy's favour since at least 1999, according to TradingView data.

The reversal has been fast. At the start of 2025, Italy paid 34 basis points more than France. The two lines crossed in September 2025, and the gap has kept widening since.

Italy now also borrows more cheaply than the UK, where the 10-year gilt yields 5. 35%, and the United States, where the 10-year Treasury yields 5. 12%.

Against Germany, the eurozone's benchmark, the BTP-Bund spread stands at 106 basis points. The spread measures the extra return investors demand to hold Italian rather than German debt. France's equivalent gap is 156 basis points, more than double the 71 basis points it started the year at.

Italy has not been immune to this year's sell-off. Its spread has widened from about 60 basis points in late February, as the war in the Middle East pushed up energy prices, inflation expectations and borrowing costs across Europe. Claus Vistesen and Melanie Debono, economists at Pantheon Macroeconomics, expect that move to unwind.

"We think the BTP-Bund spread will fall next year, more than reversing its widening this year," they said in a note on Thursday. "We look for a BTP-Bund spread of 20bp by mid-2027, from just over 100bp at the moment. "Part of their reasoning is France.

They argue that its more serious fiscal problems, along with uncertainty around next year's presidential election, will keep investors turning to Italian bonds. Even then, cheaper relative borrowing would not make Italy's debt cheap. "Yields will stay high, at just above 3%, keeping the Italian government's debt costs elevated for now," they said.

An election-year budget tests the modelThe bigger test for Italy may come from Rome itself. Giorgia Meloni's government approved its 2027 budget on 28 October, a package worth about €26 billion that is now going through Parliament. Much of it is tax relief.

For 2027 only, the 33% income tax band would be extended to earnings of up to €55,000, from €50,000. Young private-sector workers born after 1997 and earning up to €28,000 would pay a flat 1% tax on pay rises of up to €2,500. Raises from renewed labour contracts would be taxed at a flat 5% for workers earning up to €33,000.

The self-employed would be able to stay in the flat-tax regime with turnover of up to €100,000, up from €85,000. Car tax would be permanently scrapped for one insured car of up to 80 kilowatts per owner, and mothers of two or more children earning up to €40,000 would receive a tax-free €100 a month. To pay for part of it, banks and insurers face a three-point rise in corporate income tax for two years, energy companies a higher regional business tax, and the tax on financial transactions would double to 0.

8%. Italy's Court of Auditors, which oversees public spending, told lawmakers on 9 November that many of the tax breaks expire at the end of 2027 and that about 70% of the funding will not be repeated, leaving the bill to the next Parliament. The government's own fiscal plan, published in October, sees the deficit at 2.

9% of GDP this year, rising to 3. 4% in 2027 once extra defence and energy spending allowed under EU rules is included. Debt is projected to edge up to 138.

5% of GDP next year. A vote too close to callThe budget lands as Italy heads towards a general election due by autumn 2027, with growing talk in Rome of an earlier vote in the spring. The latest SWG poll for broadcaster La7, published on 9 November, put the centre-left opposition on 44.

9% and Meloni's centre-right coalition on 44%, a gap within the margin of error. Meloni's Brothers of Italy remained the largest single party on 28. 9%, while 29% of respondents did not state a preference.

Pantheon's base case is that the governing coalition survives the vote, which it sees as a further reason for the spread to stay tight through 2027. In 1992, Italy had no choice but to tighten its belt. Thirty-four years later, the rest of the G7 is being told to do the same, just as Italy is being tempted to loosen its own.

Source · Euronews ↗

Not cross-checked yet

Only Euronews reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.

The reports
  1. Euronews
    17 Nov, 07:46
Trust score: 78/100
Publisher Euronews (established tier)+76
Detailed summary+2
Total78

Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.