French public debt: “France is not going to be Greece”, says Clément Beaune
Clément Beaune, High Commissioner for Strategy and Planning was the guest of Franceinfo 7.40 this Saturday, November 14. He notably returned to the new day of social mobilization this Saturday but also to the French…
This text corresponds to the transcription of part of the interview above. Click on the video to watch the interview in full. Social anger does not subside, high school students, students, yellow vests are mobilizing again this Saturday, November 14 in the streets of France and particularly in Paris with a fifth consecutive Saturday of social mobilization.
We have the impression that, whatever the government says or does, the anger does not subside, continues and it could perhaps last until this presidential election. What do you think? Clément Beaune: We have to look at the situation as it is.
First, always distinguish social mobilizations, which are respectable and most often also respectful of public order, from what we may have experienced on certain Saturdays, which fortunately is no longer the case in recent days. Everything is done so that this is no longer the case, of violence, of breakages, we have to distinguish things each time. Then, there is still a reduction in social mobilizations.
This does not mean that there are no issues or that there is no anger, but it also undoubtedly means that a certain number of answers have been provided, including this week by the Prime Minister, by the government, on the minimum wage, on a certain number of purchasing power measures, on public transport packages and other very concrete things. Obviously, this is not enough at all. We are still expecting up to 60,000 people in the streets of Paris, for example, according to the figures.
I note that the last Saturdays, there were fewer people than the first weeks of mobilization. Is it running out of steam? You shouldn't bet on it.
That's not at all what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that there is still an effect from a certain number of social discussions and measures, no doubt. Then, there is a situation which is inevitably a little complicated, since there is a government which, whatever it can do, will not remain in charge for a short time, since we have an election in a few months.
I think that this anger must be expressed, but it also says that there is no outlet for many French people, whatever their political sensibility, in the election, in the campaign as it is done today. So, it's not that the government doesn't do things. There must be a budget, a certain number of social measures must be integrated, there is the revaluation of the minimum wage, which has been announced, but the presidential campaign must also offer social perspectives.
I try to take the long view in my current role. This is not to deny the emergencies, but it also means that there is, I think in this mobilization, the idea that for the moment, there is no political project which creates enthusiasm or which reassures on the social aspect, on protection, on purchasing power for the months or years to come. This is what worries me more than this or that mobilization of the moment.
There is no suitable candidate in this presidential election at the moment? That's not what I'm saying, but I note that it's quite rare to have social mobilizations continuing less than six months before a presidential election. There have already been mobilizations, particularly in 2001, including of police and gendarmes on a social level.
But that there is this idea, and it is worrying, of a democracy which has no outlet, that there is not a hope which is created by a democratic political moment, that is undoubtedly unprecedented. And it must, I say collectively, because I also have commitments, to question us, to challenge us about the proposals, the visions which are deployed in this campaign. You were talking about it a moment ago.
The police are unhappy too. The police officers who are still mobilized in numbers today for this day of mobilization, up to 70,000 law enforcement officers throughout the country. Will this social anger finally be added to the anger of the police?
They were received yesterday by Laurent Nuñez, the Minister of the Interior. It went very, very badly. They are threatening to strike next week, the police.
There is a process underway with the Minister of the Interior. It's not my place to get involved. Laurent Nuñez knows, and for good reason, he is also a professional in public security issues, the burden that weighs on police officers and gendarmes.
He recalls it often and sometimes a little alone. It also tells us that our police officers, our gendarmes, are human beings who have families, who have purchasing power difficulties, who are public agents, civil servants, who are public service agents, who sometimes struggle like others. And therefore, we must also understand their social difficulty.
Does a law enforcement strike worry you? The police, like all public officials, I don't like this prevailing discourse which consists of spitting on public officials. The police, the gendarmes, like all public officials, have a sense of duty.
So even when there are social discussions, mobilizations, these discussions will continue. There is a sense of application of duty, like our caregivers, like our teachers. We must also pay tribute to this sense of public service.
He is present in the police and the gendarmerie, obviously. Do you agree with former head of state Nicolas Sarkozy who says, among our colleagues in Le Figaro, that he fears a tsunami of financial crisis even before the presidential election? According to him, the question is not if there will be a crisis, but rather when.
What do you think? You have to be careful with the words. France is not going to be Greece.
There is not going to be a debt crisis as experienced by certain European countries which could no longer even finance their debt and therefore their public service on the markets. France is not in this situation. And besides, as we have seen, these are not gentle agencies, which everyone told us were going to downgrade France's rating; Moody's a few days ago did not do so.
That doesn't mean the situation isn't serious. That would be the other pitfall of considering that suddenly everything is fine. This text corresponds to part of the transcription of the report above.
Click on the video to watch it in full.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only Franceinfo reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- Franceinfo15 Nov, 10:38
| Publisher Franceinfo (established tier) | +76 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 78 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.
