"A nauseating debate", "the aspirations of the French people"... To save 1.8 million euros per year, the Senate deprives certain foreigners of family allowances for a year
In the midst of examining the Social Security budget for 2027, the Senate approved on Tuesday a contested provision to subject some non-EU foreigners to a one-year waiting period before receiving family allowances.
The Senate approved on Tuesday a contested provision of the draft Social Security budget to subject certain foreigners to a one-year waiting period on their family allowances, with the left and certain Macronists accusing the government of running behind the National Rally. Supported by the RN, the right and a majority of centrists, the measure provides that non-European foreigners in a legal situation must have resided at least one year in France to have access to the majority of family benefits (family allowances, back-to-school allowance, etc.) and to personal housing assistance (APL).
The measure would concern non-EU foreigners in a legal situation who do not have a residence permit authorizing them to work, or who are not covered by a bilateral convention. Its examination sparked lively debates in the hemicycle, with on one side a left hostile to what it describes as a "national preference" measure, and an RN which tried without success to further tighten the text to extend the waiting period, being satisfied to see one of its flagship proposals taken up. “This government has decided to give in (to the RN) and has decided to break what was a consensus around children,” regretted socialist Laurence Rossignol.
Certain social benefits are already conditional on a period of residence for foreign nationals, such as the Active Solidarity Income (RSA), subject to having held a residence permit authorizing them to work for five years, or the Solidarity Allowance for the Elderly (Aspa, 10 years). “A question of proportionate justice” Several senators accused the government of having included this provision to obtain clemency from the RN at the end of the budgetary debates. “If in the remainder of the procedure, you obtain non-censorship of the National Rally group, we will know why and the disgust will be complete,” argued Bernard Jomier (Place publique).
Senator RN Aymeric Durox, on the contrary, affirmed that the measure responded to “the aspirations of the French people who want to stop massive immigration, who want to stop social benefits for foreigners”. “This article raises a question of proportionate justice,” defended Minister of Health Stéphanie Rist, recalling that “people who work” will not be affected. Several Macronist and center elected officials have expressed their discomfort with this proposal, which will only bring in 1.8 million euros for Social Security in a full year.
The president of the Renaissance senators, Xavier Iacovelli, notably castigated the "uselessness" of the measure, "apart from creating a nauseating debate in our Assembly and in the country". Only 132 senators voted to delete this article, against 206 for its maintenance.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only BFM Business reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- BFM Business17 Nov, 18:38
| Publisher BFM Business (established tier) | +76 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 78 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.
