A defrauded customer must now be immediately reimbursed by his bank, rules the Court of Justice of the European Union
According to the Banque de France, conflicts between customers and banking establishments are increasing. Some customers who are victims of a bank scam are compensated but in other cases the banks refuse to reimburse.
In 2025, the capture of fraudulent transfers by scammers increased by 37% (485 million euros) and scams through manipulation, such as the fake bank advisor scam, jumped by 34% (516 million euros) in France, according to data from the Payment Means Security Observatory. The Banque de France specifies for its part that the number of frauds has doubled in the space of 4 years.
Behind these figures, there are tens of thousands of customers whose bank accounts have been severely siphoned off, if not completely emptied. The following question then arises: who should pay? A question that has agitated for years the courts responsible for arbitrating conflicts between banks and their customers who are victims of scams.
Until now, certain banks have been ordered to reimburse the amount of the losses, because the courts considered that it was their duty to protect the liquidity of their customers (Court of Cassation, judgment no. 586 FS-B of October 23, 2024). Then the banking establishments pleaded “gross negligence”. Thus, under certain conditions, customers fooled by the scammers did not have the right to compensation for the damage since they had “lacked vigilance” (Court of Cassation, judgment nᵒ 4 FS-B of January 15, 2025).
LCL and BNP Paribas increase their banking fees: here is what the 14 million customers will pay in 2027
The Yellow Pages pay him 445,000 euros after dismissing him from his hospital bed
Faced with these constant reversals, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has ruled. Originally referred to the Polish courts, the institution responsible for the application of European law had to answer a simple question: "Is a bank obliged to immediately reimburse the amount of an unauthorized transaction, even if it considers that the client has committed serious negligence?"
In its judgment, delivered on October 15, the CJEU's response is clear. Yes, the bank is obliged to reimburse immediately! Indeed, the magistrates of the highest court notably analyzed article 73 of the 2nd European directive on payment services (PSD2). The text clearly indicates that the victim's bank "must reimburse immediately, and at the latest by the end of the first working day following that on which it became aware of the fraudulent transaction". There is only one exception: if the bank has reason to suspect intentional fraud on the part of the customer himself.
This ruling from the CJEU does not, however, mean that the victim of fraud is always right. If the bank manages to provide evidence of serious negligence on the part of the customer at the time the fraudulent transaction took place, it may claim reimbursement of the compensation it paid beforehand.
However, the CJEU's decision will allow victims of fraud to be reimbursed directly, without having to embark on a long, expensive and discouraging legal procedure against the banking establishment.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only Journal du Net reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- Journal du Net21 Nov, 06:55
| Publisher Journal du Net (general tier) | +72 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 74 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.
