Presidential Election 2027: But what exactly is funded retirement? We explain to you
They are a pair of presidential candidates who no longer consider it a taboo to include a share of capitalization in the financing of pensions. But what exactly is funded retirement?
Gabriel Attal, Bruno Retailleau, David Lisnard and even Marine le Pen... All these candidates for the 2027 presidential election have spoken out in favor of including a more or less significant dose of compulsory capitalization in the French pension system, until now very largely based on distribution. To judge what this entails, you still need to know what capitalization retirement is. We'll explain it to you.
In France currently, it is the assets which largely finance the pensions of retirees, a principle of solidarity called “retirement by distribution”, explains Henri Sterdyniak, economist at the OFCE specializing in pensions (retirement). Concretely, on the pay slip, this corresponds to the compulsory deduction lines “capped old age insurance”, “uncapped old age insurance” and “supplementary pension”. That is to say almost 212 euros per month of employee share and 199 euros per month of employer share for a minimum wage salary.
The everyone for themselves principle Capitalization retirement is the opposite principle: everyone finances their own retirement. “Every month you save money which is invested in the financial markets, and this gives you the right to a retirement pension calculated according to the accumulated amount,” explains Henri Sterdyniak. Basically, instead of paying 412 euros each month for today's retirees, we invest this money which will be released when we ourselves are retired.
To the ear, the term “funded retirement” sounds a bit American. And the fact is that yes, it is something particularly developed in the United States. Realize: according to OECD figures, in 2025, the cumulative assets of all funded pension plans in the United States (pension funds, retirement insurance contracts, funds managed by banks or investment companies) represented 49 million million dollars.
Except that even in the United States, there is “social security”, a basic foundation operating on the principle of distribution. Exiting the pay-as-you-go system is impossible. Moreover, funded retirement already exists in most OECD countries, including in Europe and… in France. “These are, for example, retirement savings plans, which operate on a voluntary basis and complement the basic pension,” explains the economist.
Obviously, as these are contributions in addition to others, the cumulative assets of the funded pension in France are much lower than in the United States. That said, still according to the OECD, the jackpot was still 403 billion euros in 2025. According to Henri Sterdyniak, no retirement system in the world operates solely through capitalization - indeed, that does not exist anywhere -.
“In any case, it is not possible to exit the pay-as-you-go system, even for supplementary retirement, since that would amount to sacrificing a generation which would have to pay twice,” assures the economist. According to him, the proposal to introduce a compulsory part of funded pension is not a good idea either, since it “is equivalent to making employees bear an additional compulsory deduction”.
Machine-translated from French
Not cross-checked yet
Only 20 Minutes reports this story so far. We show it as a single source until another newsroom confirms it.
- 20 Minutes18 Nov, 08:07
| Publisher 20 Minutes (general tier) | +72 |
| Detailed summary | +2 |
| Total | 74 |
Method: reports are grouped by the words of their headline and summary; each newsroom counts once; figures are read from the reports as published. Nothing here is written by an AI.